Family Money: Funds of Funds
By Leslie
Wright,
Managing director of Westminster Portfolio Services (Thailand) Ltd.
Growing Popularity
Since the mid-1990s funds-of-funds have been growing in
number, and now there are well over 150 available. Just over half are run
as a mixture of equity and fixed income, on an aggressive, balanced or
cautious basis. The rest are primarily equity funds.
There are regional funds-of-funds (global, European,
North American and Japan, for instance) and specialist funds-of-funds -
for example, there’s an “ethical” funds-of-funds, and there’s even
a technology fund-of-funds for those with strong stomachs.
Tax Benefits
There is a strong technical reason for considering a
fund-of-funds product. You can buy units in a fund-of-funds with, say, a
balanced portfolio.
Alternatively, you could buy a similar balanced
selection of funds directly. But in the latter case, whenever you wish to
switch holdings, you realise a capital gain on any profits you may have
made. If everything is held within a fund-of-funds instead, the manager
can switch funds on your behalf without creating an immediate tax
liability.
Of course, small UK investors are unlikely to reach the
annual exemption limit for capital gains - ฃ7,900 for the 2003~2004
tax year - but it is still a potential liability, especially if the market
rises sharply.
Costs
In theory, then, funds-of-funds sound great. But in
practice, there is rather more to them.
The main drawback is the double layer of charges: you
have to pay fees on the underlying funds as well as those for the
fund-of-funds manager. With annual charges for most funds averaging
between 1~1.5%, an extra 1% for the fund-of-funds management means total
annual charges of up to 2.5%.
If that basket of funds is going to outperform the
fund’s benchmark index by more than 1% a year, it’s worth the extra
1%; but very few actively-managed unit trusts do outperform their index.
Stock market returns are lower nowadays, and getting 6~7% with income
reinvested means that an extra 1% on the fee equals 13% of the return.
It’s certainly a gamble that would not have paid off
in the majority of cases in recent years. For the three years to 14 July,
the average return for actively-managed funds-of-funds was minus 31.25%,
compared with minus 31.24% for all active-managed funds, including
funds-of-funds (Source: Standard & Poor’s, bid price to bid price,
income reinvested). However, over the same period, balanced-managed
funds-of-funds beat their overall peer group - losing 23.65%, compared
with 24.84% overall. And cautious managed funds-of-funds lost 5.56%,
compared with 6.29% overall. Small differences, perhaps, but significant.
But the argument that funds-of-funds are ideal for
cautious investors is refuted by the fact that a low-risk investor
wouldn’t want to be in equities anyway. Funds-of-funds are more for
medium to high-risk investors who are prepared to invest for the long term
in equities. And even then, in the vast majority of cases they have little
to offer: the capital gains tax advantage is the only thing going for
them.
The comparatively high total charges can also be
reduced if the fund can only invest in in-house funds. While this may not
be an ideal arrangement, given that even the best investment house is
unlikely to have a strong track record right across the board, it does
make the fund cheaper to run as the managers are likely to get discounts
on switches. However, most funds-of-funds are actually unfettered: they
can invest in the whole range of funds in their sector, regardless of who
manages them.
With in-house fettered funds, the total expense ratio
is a bit lower than for unfettered. For example, there might not be any
exit or entry charges, and the annual management fee might be lower. And
fettered funds-of-funds can give you access to the best managers of a good
house. Unfettered funds will get a good deal, but not as good.
One well-known investment house - BestInvest -
recommends a fettered fund-of-funds: the Threadneedle Global Equity &
Bond Fund. They also like Fidelity’s Moneybuilder, Global Portfolio and
Wealthbuilder funds, which are all fettered, and all run by Richard Skelt.
If you look at the performance in the active-managed
sector over the past three years, there is a disproportionately large
number of funds-of-funds in the top quartile. Since the market has
bottomed out, a number of these funds have done very well.
Lessons To Learn
But even if you prefer to pick your own funds, the
methodology used by funds-of-funds managers can offer pointers as to what
you should be looking for.
One leading fund manager points out: “There is not
one ideal unit trust out there. We try to build a balanced, blended
portfolio where we can get repeatability. We aim to put together a
portfolio of best styles and best approaches, so the fund outperforms when
the market goes both up and down.” The investment process used by the
funds under consideration is a key factor in this decision, he says.
Part of his approach is to marry two opposing styles.
“For instance, we hold both the value-driven JO Hambro Capital
Management European Fund and the growth-driven New Star European Growth
Fund. We then try to blend these so we can still replicate the market and
its risk, but in different ways. That means when mid-cap growth performs,
we do well, and we also do well when large-cap value performs. We’re not
clever enough to chase the market on a day-to-day basis,” he says. I
wish all my clients were as modest!
Another house uses a number of performance filters,
which include consistency, risk-adjusted returns and momentum. The
momentum filter analyses which funds are in the top quartile on a rolling
year-to-year basis, so it indicates which type of funds are doing well,
such as large-cap or value funds. Funds may also appear in this group for
other reasons, perhaps because of a change of manager or a change in
approach.
At the other end of the spectrum is the GAM UK
Diversified Fund, run by Andrew Green. This is the purest kind of
contrarian fund which buys bombed-out stocks at the bottom. Because he
buys these stocks early, there are extreme deviations from the market, but
it’s worth waiting through the underperformance to reap the rewards.
Another fund manager says they look to blend different
styles, to get a mixture of funds that perform at different times in the
market cycle.
However, most managers agree that spectacular
out-performance is impossible: “You would never expect a fund-of-funds
to be top of the table in its sector because you’re investing in such a
broad spread,” says one, “and there’s no way you could beat the best
fund.”
Personal Directions: Don’t look back
By Christina Dodd,
founder and managing director of Asia Training Associates
Have you woken up one morning to find that you have woken
up to one of the worst days in your life? We all have woken up to nightmares!
And the thing is we think that we are the only ones having a bad day or time
or life! Nothing can console us and we are oblivious to others who are having
perhaps an even worse time of it. Nothing is wrong with this ... such is our
nature.
Getting through bad and difficult times is tough ... it
really is. Very few people are endowed with the patience and the coolness of
thought required to tackle emergencies. Few of us collect our thoughts and
emotions and tackle the task at hand in a measured way. We are human beings
and our emotions tend to take charge first.
But there comes a time in our development where we should
be able to take hold of “the wild horse pulling us along in the stampede.”
No matter what the event, we have to be able to, at some stage in our personal
development as adults say, “Hey human being, come on and settle down.
Let’s take a look at this first.” Some people can do this and do it very
well. They view the situation with calm and clarity and then make a plan of
action. Other people, and I would think most people, are not capable of this
at all. Or is it that they are capable and just don’t know it!
The reason I am talking on this subject is that I am
increasingly meeting more and more men and women who are suddenly finding
themselves on the receiving end of the “downsizing stick”. This is the
nightmare they are now waking up to. It used to be the case that this never
happened in Thailand. But it is on the rise and has been for quite some years,
and those affected would of course never admit it to anyone.
In my travels and meetings with people who are presently
living this experience, it is extremely important to try to inspire confidence
and enthusiasm in them after such a “defeat” in their careers and lives.
It is no easy task to do. Not at all. When such an event touches people it can
have severe consequences. Overcoming the depression that accompanies the loss
of a job is like trying to put out a fire with petrol. But in spite of this,
the battle to overcome the present “temporary” defeat must go on. No
matter how difficult and impossible it all may seem, the fight has to
continue.
Human beings react to failure, loss, defeat, in various
ways. And some react in the extreme. Some cannot pick themselves up as well as
others. Some find it an enormous struggle to find their way again. Some find
the obstacles too overwhelming and give up. Some need more guidance and care
through a time that they thought would never enter their lives.
For individuals affected by downsizing or for companies who
are “having to let people go”, a strategy - let’s say a future path or
exit strategy - is an absolute necessity. At Asia Training Associates we have
created our own Future Path Program “Don’t Look Back”, designed
specifically and on a very personal level to assist individuals going through
this experience.
The name itself, Don’t Look Back, reflects the positive
nature of the elements that bind this program together giving it dynamic force
and energy to the individual participants. We don’t sit and sympathize and
sip tea, we begin with acceptance of the situation and analysis of what went
wrong. It is in a way a reality check and as such is an extremely important
step of letting go and finding focus. Assessing the past, looking at the
present in order to face a positive future.
It’s all about learning to walk again and identifying new
possibilities. It’s about thinking in a different way to the norm or how you
used to think. It’s about finding the challenge in the situation you are in
and working out ways of meeting that challenge. Becoming motivated to overcome
the fears of change allows you to find the courage to succeed. In this process
you also learn ways to be calm in the face of fire and to bind every strength
together for the ultimate victory.
The program looks heavily at goals and the goal-setter, the
reality of goals as opposed to dreams. It helps the individual identify, set,
prioritize and plan. It looks at needs and actions, learning from past
experiences in order to build and initiate. Knowing what to expect from
others, knowing what others expect from you.
It covers all aspects of getting organized and provides the
nuts and bolts of what you need to do in terms of resumes, interviews,
contacts, networking, identifying support bases and so on. Preparation and
planning are paramount to success and this program takes you through every key
area.
An integral session of the program is, “So what’s
stopping you!”, which takes into account the abilities of the individual to
succeed. It brings alive the “You can do it” spirit and reinforces
self-confidence and self-esteem. It re-ignites personal belief, faith and
desire in oneself to achieve and to come out winning! Don’t Look Back is a
new step forward in a new direction and future. It is a truly rewarding
program.
To fight and win the battles that are constantly
confronting us in today’s harsh world, we have to equip ourselves with every
possible weapon. The best weapon of all is developing the ability and power
“within ourselves” to stand straight and to stand and walk tall in the
face of adversity. We possess immense capabilities within us to achieve and
succeed. If we come out fighting with the correct tools and focus ... We Will
Win!
If you are interested in our Don’t Look Back program and
indeed other areas of training we provide, please contact me at Christina .dodd@
asiatrainingasso ciates.com and take a moment to visit our website. We promise
you, You Won’t Look Back! Until next time, have a great week.
The Doctor's Consultation:
Several good reasons to avoid getting old!
by Dr. Iain Corness
Picked up a medical textbook the other day (Pattaya
International Hospital Treatment Manual 2003) and it opened at a section
called ‘Geriatric Medicine’ and what a depressing start to the day that
was! Gloom, doom and disaster! However, the picture is not really as bad as
all that, so I thought that this week I would go through the aging process,
and then what we can do about it. The recipe for the elixir of youth is not
enclosed, but instead, some ways you can stay feeling ‘young’!
Let’s begin with the depressing news that you have
actually been going downhill since the age of 14 (mentally) and from the age
of around 30 (physically). That bar-room ditty that relates to what you used
to do all night, now taking all night to do, can be too close to the mark for
some of us. But don’t despair, help is at hand.
The book suggested that the aging of our individual organs
is influenced by diet, environment, personal habits and genetic factors. Read
that again - did you notice that three of them (diet, environment, habits) are
actually under our control, so the angle of the slippery slide can be changed.
Good News number one.
The physiological changes associated with aging include an
increase in body fat, a difficulty in reading and a clouding of the optic
lens. Glucose metabolism goes a little awry as well, as we get older. In the
lungs, the elasticity goes out of the lung tissue, meaning that the lungs
don’t absorb the oxygen as well as they should.
It doesn’t end there. The arteries become less elastic
too, so the heart has to pump harder to force the blood around, increasing
blood pressure and enlarging the heart. The liver doesn’t cope as well with
toxic chemicals as it used to, and the bowel gets a little lazy as well,
leading to constipation. For men, the prostate slowly enlarges and makes it
difficult for the bladder to empty properly, so you have to get up to pee a
few times a night. Finally, the brain shrinks and you begin to forget things,
“I’ll never forget what’s-her-name” being a real problem!
So what to do? The main thing is to make sure your organs
get enough oxygen to work properly. Oxygen gets into the blood via the lungs.
Clogged air sacs in the lungs is a big problem. Answer? Stop smoking -
immediately, and get some exercise every day, so that you start to use the
lungs, and their capacity, again.
Now we have some oxygen back in the blood we have to
circulate the magic red fluid. Cholesterol build-up in the arteries produces
blockages. Reverse it by lowering cholesterol in your diet. You do this by
decreasing animal fats and increasing vegetables. That’s not too difficult
either, is it?
Now the sugar problems. Another one with an easy fix - cut
out all the ‘extra’ sugar in your diet. You don’t have to use sugar in
your coffee, and chocolates should be a very occasional indulgence only.
The liver? The main toxic substance it has to deal with is
ethanol, otherwise known as booze. Give the liver one day a week to recover.
That’s your AFD (alcohol free day).
So look at the three items again under your control - diet,
environment, habits. The answer to aging is there. Begin with fags, fat, booze
and fancy foods. It’s the right start.
Agony Column
Dear Hillary,
I would like to take you to task over your suggestions to the man you
called ‘Generous George’ and described by you as being the ‘family
cash cow’ (September 20). You infer that the situation is all ‘give
and take’ with the Thai family doing all the taking, while George does
all the giving. What you are ignoring is the fact that George has been
taking too. He admits, in his own words, “The association has been
mutually beneficial, with me enjoying her company and the attentiveness
for which Thai women are so famous.” George is trying to have his cake
and eat it at the same time. I am from the UK and I would like to ask
George what did he leave back in the home country? He said he is a
widower, so he had no mutually beneficial relationship, and not much
likely to find one either. What George has found out is that the famous
Thai attentiveness comes at a price. You get nothing for nothing and men
all over the world forget this. They think they deserve a free ride in
life, but nothing in life is free. George has made his bed, he should now
lie in it, and meet the dues that the society he has chosen to live in
expects.
Wilma
Dear Wilma,
Is your bra on fire? Even if not, the rest of you seems to be, my Petal. I
think you are being unfair to George, and to me. Is there some unwritten
law that has been broken here? George is in a relationship involving his
Thai wife and himself. This does not mean that George has to forget his
own roots and ideas. What George and his Thai wife have to do is to work
out between them what they, as a couple, want to do. This is not a
one-sided arrangement as you would appear to be promoting. George was not
asking for a free ride, but was more enquiring what the bus fare should
be. Wilma, you should learn to be more understanding. It will make you a
nicer person and give people like George less reason to flee their native
shores and come to Thailand.
Dear Hillary,
It is usually the chicks that complain about their guys and the footy,
watching the telly and all. This time the letter is from a feller who
doesn’t like football, but my bird does. I want to go to the pub and she
wants to stay home and watch Manchester or Arsenal, all the players have
unpronounceable names that she can’t say anyway, and as far as I can see
they are all big girls blouses, all lying there pretending they’ve been
hurt. What can I do to break her of this craziness?
Left Right Out
Dear Left Right Out,
If you did not realize it, Thailand is crazy about David Beckham, and he
has no L’s or R’s in his name so is easily pronounced. If Beckham
isn’t playing, then anyone in a red or white football shirt will do.
This is a very difficult habit to break, my Petal. Be prepared for a
showdown of “Football or me!” Be prepared for football to win. Be
prepared to go to the pub by yourself or learn to like Beckham. As far as
lying on the field and moaning a lot, I notice that a yellow card seems to
bring about a cure. I think they should try some of these magic cards in
the local hospitals. Think of the saving in plaster casts.
Dear Hillary,
I am very confused. Last night in the bar I met the most beautiful girl.
She is not like the other girls I have met in bars here. I have seen quite
a few as I have been in Thailand for two weeks. I have never seen anyone
as gorgeous as this girl, she is tall even taller than me with long black
hair and a super figure. She can speak English but whispers in my ear
rather than talking out loud in the noisy bar. Hillary, I am worried
because she seems so reluctant to talk that she may have something wrong
with her throat. Could laryngitis be a symptom of some other disease, even
AIDS perhaps? I feel I have to know before I go any further in this
relationship. I would hate to find that I would have to be a nursemaid to
her or lose her to some terminal illness. Can you tell me how to check?
Confused
Dear Confused,
Before you rush off to the Ear, Nose and Throat department, I think you
would be better off checking with the Gender Reassignment department. Tall
gorgeous creatures with husky voices are more than likely to be the same
sex as yourself Mr. Confused. And you have been here two weeks and you are
rushing headlong into love far too soon. It has been said many times
that the best looking girls in Thailand are always guys! You have been
warned. Slow down, Confused, and stick to girls smaller than yourself. It
is much safer.
|
Camera Class: Processing - the hitchhiker’s guide to photoshops
by Harry Flashman
I believe that the first rule of photography is nothing to do
with Keeping the Sun Over Your Left Shoulder, or similar sage words, but should
be to Always Question Your Photoprocessor. Harsh words? Perhaps. But with
today’s fully automatic cameras, and today’s fully automatic processing
machines, there should be very few occasions when you get your photographs back
and they have turned out not as you expected.
Take
a look at the two shots, taken in the Grampian Mountains in Scotland. The purple
flowers and dark rolling hills looked particularly photogenic. The shot was
taken in the Auto Mode, and should not have been too difficult for the
camera’s meter to work out a suitable exposure. Likewise, the negative should
not have been too difficult for the photoprocessor to handle, but that’s where
it all went wrong.
The
initial print that was given back in Scotland was very dark. The sky was a
beautiful blue with pure white clouds, but the purple flowers were lost in the
dark vegetation, and the standing figure in the mid-ground had almost
disappeared. I checked the negative, and all the important details were in
there, but not in the final print. For reasons known only to the
photoprocessor’s brain, it had decided that the sky was the most important
feature and made the print to suit.
Taking the negative back to the photoprocessor produced the
lighter print, where the details in the vegetation were better, the purple
flowers purple again, but the sky was a little ‘blown out’. However, this
was much better than the initial print.
The fact that you must always remember is that the
photoprocessing machine, is just that - a machine. It really has no idea what it
is looking at, just a mixture of colours and tones and it makes arbitrary
decisions as to what is the most important area of the photograph. Most times it
will coincide with what the photographer wanted - but sometimes there will be
glaring mistakes.
What you must do is not to be frightened by the machines, or
their operators - who are normally all lovely young ladies with sweet smiles.
All you have to do is to take the print back to them and show them what you
want. With darker or lighter, this is easily done at the twiddle of a knob.
With colours, this is not quite as simple, as screwing up the
reds can affect the blues, but again this can be subtly changed. This is
particularly so for skin tones. Thai girls with that beautiful dusky hue in
their skin should not come back looking like pink westerners with almond shaped
eyes. Even when you drop the film off, a word to the girls that you want the
skin tones to “look Thai” can mean you will have to do fewer trips to ask
for reprints. There are always limitations with print film as we know it, but
other than fluorescent colours, today’s photoprocessors can go reasonably
close.
So how do you pick a good photoprocessing shop? This can be
difficult, but busy places are usually better than ones that only do a few rolls
of film a day. The reason for this is that the busy shops generally change the
chemicals more frequently, and the operators are more experienced, so know what
to do.
So where do I go? Since I travel all over Thailand these
days, I have different places I go to, but when in Chiang Mai I have used
Combine Photo Express (Fuji), next to KFC in the lower floor of Kad Suan Kaew
and have received good work, and when in Pattaya I use Royal Express on Pattaya
Second Road, just past Golden Beach Hotel, whose girls have always given me
great service, with consistent attention to detail, for many years.
Chiangmai Mail Publishing Co. Ltd.
209/5 Moo 6, T.Faham,
A.Muang, Chiang Mai 50000
Tel. 0 5385 2557 Fax. 0 5326 0738
e-mail: cnxmail@chiangmai-mail.com
www.chiangmai-mail.com
Administration: md@chiangmai-mail.com
Advertising: advertising@chiangmai-mail.com
sales@chiangmai-mail.com
Subscription: subscription@chiangmai-mail.com
Copyright © 2004 Chiangmai Mail. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
|