Graham Macdonald, MBE
MBMG International Ltd.
Nominated for the Lorenzo Natali Prize
Surfing the Waves
I will abscond from writing this week and quote verbatim from my business
partner’s blog which you can find on the MBMG website. Paul says: My
colleague Steve Hinch is Australian-American - that probably goes some way
to explaining his interest in both surfing and in technical analysis of
capital markets. I’ve never mastered surfing and I’ve tended to be extremely
sceptical about the most extreme output of ‘chartists’ but I’ve taken the
liberty of forwarding Steve’s latest research outpourings that features both
of his favoured activities.
To be fair to Steve, I would point out that much of his interest in charts
revolves around longer term cycles that more fundamentalist economists like
me also pay heed to. In many ways at this intersection of both fundamental
and technical each tends to reinforce the other, although they don’t always
afford mutual respect and recognition. (Murray Rothbard constructed the most
compelling dissection of the business cycle - which fits perfectly with
Nikolai Kondratieff’s long term cycles - but then felt the need to write a
rebuttal of Kondratieff and most other forms of cycle.) Since commerce
began, the history has been a 4 season cycle of:
Growth-> Leverage-> Leverage-fuelled growth-> The burst of the leverage
The best fundamental understandings of economic cycles recognize this. So do
the best technical constructs. In the right hands, these come together in a
harmony of understanding and insight.
Enough said, let’s look at what Steve had to say.
Riding the wave… Catching the base of the wave is always
Most surfers understand that to get the best ride, you have to
meet the wave at base as it is at this point you can get the most lift.
When it comes to waves, one of the most fascinating areas of interest in
economics has been that introduced by Russian Nikolai Kondratiev whose
analysis points to a 60 year economic wave cycle going through.
Nikolai Kondratiev was shot by firing squad on the orders of Stalin in 1938.
He died for what he believed was the truth. His execution was ordered
because his academic work propounded that the capitalist system would not
collapse as a result of the great depression of 1929. This truth Stalin did
not want to hear, thus Nikolai was exterminated and his work suppressed for
over two decades.
Kondratiev’s analysis described how international capitalism had gone
through many such cycles and as such was a normal part of the international
mercantile credit system. The long wave cycles that he identified through
meticulous research are now called “Kondratieff” cycles or “K” waves.
The K wave is a 60 year cycle (+/- a year or so) with internal phases that
are sometimes characterized as seasons: spring, summer, autumn and winter:
* Spring phase: a new factor of production, good economic times, rising
* Summer: hubristic ‘peak’ war followed by societal doubts and double digit
* Autumn: the financial fix of inflation leads to a credit boom which
creates a false plateau of prosperity that ends in a speculative bubble
* Winter: excess capacity worked off by massive debt repudiation, commodity
deflation & economic depression.
Implications for 2013 and Beyond
Many analysts seem to accept as fact, that most winters in K
cycles last 20 years. However, history shows us that there is not that total
consistency. While most long cycle waves last around 60 years, the length of
the recessionary winter declines phase seems to depend on the length of the
autumn peak maturity of the wave.
For example, in the first wave shown in the chart which ran for 55 years
from 1789 until 1844, the Autumn peak phase ran for 19 years and the
corresponding winter recession was short running for 9 years. The next cycle
ran for just 42 years from 1854 until 1896, the autumn peak phase was a
short 10 year cycle and followed by a long 22 year recessionary winter
phase. The next cycle ran for 52 years, from 1897 until 1949, the autumn
peak phase in this case was a short 9 years and subsequently the winter
recession phase was a long drawn out 20 years. The current long wave cycle
we now find the world in commenced in the heydays of 1950 and has been a
long cycle running for 62 years to date.
We are now in the final stage of this long cycle which is the winter
deflationary cycle. As pointed out earlier, many analysts have suggested the
average winter cycle is 20 years. However, as I have shown, there has not
been an average, but the length of the winter cycle appears to be dependent
on the length of autumn peak. History suggests that the longer the autumn
peak - the shorter the winter downturn. In the current long wave cycle the
recent autumn peak ran from 1982 to 2000 or a total of 19 years, making this
a long phase autumn cycle, suggesting the winter cycle will be shorter, or
based on history between 9 and 11 years. Thus in all probability we are now
setting the base to start moving from a “winter recession” to a “spring”
phase in the near future. The beginning of a new long wave!
Like all cycles, K wave analysis is more “descriptive than prescriptive”,
but provides enormous insight into our current economic condition. Such
evidence also supports the proposition that the central bank intervention
may simply be prolonging the agony through 5 trillion of credit expansion
and they should liberate the “international market” and let it intelligently
and efficiently do what it has done 18 times before.
Central banks and governments have spent other people’s money to try to save
and return to the glory days of this long wave cycle. They will not accept
that the old cycle must end. The passing of the old provides the room for a
new global economy through innovation, hard work and capital formation. More
debt that is only seeking to save banks and businesses best left to their
just rewards is not the answer.
In the current K wave, debt has driven excess capacity in banking, autos,
manufacturing, retail, etc. There is not sufficient demand to keep up with
the debt-financed overproduction and supply of everything. Only politicians
scrambling for their political survival think the debt binge can go on
forever. It cannot and it will not. The debt game is coming to its final K
Fortunately, it is not all gloom and doom. The good news is that after this
destructive period is over the world economy will be ready for a new spring
boom which will propel it to new levels of political, social and economic
There remains the chance that the phenomenon of emerging markets will limit
the damage of the ending of this long wave. The final systemic shock phase
could be short and V shaped. Dozens of new countries are embracing and
integrating with international free market capitalism. Even former communist
China has joined international free market capitalism. China does not
represent a new civilization; it is integrating into western civilization.
Just like the surfer who is ready to position himself at the base of the
wave, so to should investors be ready to position themselves at the base of
the new wave/cycle… how soon will this be?
Well just as the surfer does, you have to be patient and watch for signs and
then be ready to act.
The above data and
research was compiled from sources believed to be reliable.
However, neither MBMG International Ltd nor its officers can
accept any liability for any errors or omissions in the above
article nor bear any responsibility for any losses achieved as a
result of any actions taken or not taken as a consequence of
reading the above article. For more information please contact
Graham Macdonald on [email protected]