A Thlonely, fragile, haunting little ballad “New York Mining Disaster 1941”
came floating across the airwaves in April 1967. Everybody thought it was a
secret Beatles-release. The melody and arrangement were painfully beautiful,
Robin Gibb’s voice so sad you wanted to cuddle it, and the words… what was
that all about, a horrible mining disaster back in 1941, a guy buried
underground, all alone in the darkness, hoping for rescue, waiting for
death. The fact that there never was a mining disaster in New York in 1941
made the recording even more mysterious. Who were these guys, did they exist
The Bee Gees would prove to be real enough. Three brothers from the Isle Of
Man (the family emigrated to Redcliffe, Australia in 1958) and two hired
guns from Down Under (who had become permanent members when “Bee Gees 1st”
came out). In 1966, after eight frustrating years of struggle the brothers
Gibb had finally become local stars thanks to the “Spicks And Specs”-single.
Then they left it all behind and sailed off for England. “Bee Gees 1st” was
not their first LP, but rather their third. But “1st” was a much more useful
moniker than “3rd” to build a new career on. In a way they started from
scratch, with a wonder of an album.
The 14 cuts still sound as fresh, mysterious and beautiful as they did 46
years ago. Every song is built around catchy, but gentle melodies lifted by
magnificent harmonic singing. Barry and Robin share the lead vocals between
them just like John and Paul did on The Beatles’ records. The gorgeous,
elaborate arrangements give every song its own identity, this too very much
in the spirit of the Liverpudlians.
Like The Beatles their music evolves from the basic beat group set-up of
guitars, bass, drums and eventually keyboards, adding mellotron and
orchestra, but never overdoing anything; every detail is there for a reason,
nothing gets in the way of song and performance.
The album sounds so effortless, elegant and mature to come from a new
unproven and young band. It is advanced pop music, airy, colourful and easy
on the ear. The careful use of classical elements and light psychedelia
increases the album’s magic, it slides perfectly in where it belongs, in the
slipstream of “Sgt. Pepper” (though actually recorded before Pepper was
finished), a true participant in the summer of love.
The stereo separation is typical for its time, limited as they were by the
four track tape recorder, but that sound has its own unmistakable charm. I
am very fond of the way the strings are recorded, dry, close-miked, in your
face, just as the Beatles did it.
If Barry and Robin are the voices of the album, Maurice sure is its soul. A
gifted bass player, as important for the early Bee Gees-sound as McCartney
was for The Beatles, his melodic, syncopated and springy runs were copied by
numerous young players. He was also a wizard on the mellotron, way ahead of
most players at the time (The Moody Blues could never have bettered what he
does to “Every Christian Lion Hearted Man Will Show You”).
The three hit singles from the album, “New York Mining Disaster 1941”, “To
Love Somebody” and the US only “Holiday” are all slow, melancholy ballads.
But those tracks are just one part of the story as the rest of the album is
quite up-tempo, taking the listener on a joyful ride through the same
soundscapes as “Revolver” did. It’s very much a rock record, chock-full of
hooks and eclectic turns, commerciality and psychedelia, comedy and whimsy.
There was something for everybody.
A track like “To Love Somebody” would be covered by both soul and country
singers – even Leonard Cohen. The sheer quality of the Gibb brothers’
writing transcended the time and style they were recorded in.
I still prefer the originals though. “Bee Gees’ 1st” is simply a delight all
the way from the baroque intro to “Turn Of The Century” to the fading drama
of “Close Another Door”.
The sleeve design matches its contents. A summery photo of the band gently
lowered into Klaus Voormans’ organic and colourful psychedelia.
The brothers Gibb were a horn of plenty and a gift to humankind. Six months
and three outstanding hit singles later, the Bee Gees had a new strong album
ready for the Christmas market. Even greater successes were to come. But
nothing they ever did later would recapture the freshness and naive beauty
of “Bee Gees 1st”. How could they. We were soldiers once… and young.
Released: July 1967
(All songs written and composed by Barry and Robin Gibb except where noted)
1. “Turn of the Century” 2:25
2. “Holiday” 2:53
3. “Red Chair, Fade Away” 2:16
4. “One Minute Woman” 2:18
5. “In My Own Time” 2:15
6. “Every Christian Lion Hearted Man Will Show You” (Barry Gibb, Robin Gibb,
Maurice Gibb) 3:38
7. “Craise Finton Kirk Royal Academy of Arts” 2:16
1. “New York Mining Disaster 1941” 2:09
2. “Cucumber Castle” Barry 2:04
3. “To Love Somebody” Barry 3:00
4. “I Close My Eyes” (Barry Gibb, Robin Gibb, Maurice Gibb) 2:22
5. “I Can’t See Nobody” 3:45
6. “Please Read Me” 2:15
7. “Close Another Door” (Barry Gibb, Robin Gibb, Maurice Gibb) 3:29
The Bee Gees:
Barry Gibb — lead, harmony and backing vocal, guitar
Robin Gibb — lead, harmony and backing vocal, organ
Maurice Gibb — harmony and backing vocal, bass, piano, organ, harpsichord,
Vince Melouney — guitar
Colin Petersen — drums
Additional personnel and production:
Phil Dennys — orchestral arrangement on “New York Mining Disaster 1941”,
“Red Chair Fade Away”, “I Close My Eyes” and “One Minute Woman”
Bill Shepherd — orchestral arrangement
Mike Claydon — engineer
Robert Stigwood — producer
Ossie Byrne — producer
Klaus Voormann — art cover