Life at 33 1/3
By Carl Meyer
All downhill from here
The Rolling Stones: Goat’s Head Soup (Rolling Stones Records)
Of course I had to wait until the Stones had reached their zenith and were
slowly starting to roll downhill before I went to see them for the first
time: Gothenburg, 1973. The circus was in town. Decadence had replaced
hunger, they were loaded and delivered kitsch rather than inspired
greatness. It would get worse, but at the time they looked impressive,
stadium rock was still a new thing. Lots of lights and colours, lots of
everything, lavish, spectacular, Mick jumping all over the stage, posing,
hips shaking, the professional show band flirting with its own myth.
I felt cheated. I had come too late. Why didn’t I see them in ’65 when they
played in Oslo?
“Goat’s Head Soup” was the first Stones album I got for free. The first
Stones album I related to as a critic. Unfortunately it was also the Stones
album where the band had lost the plot. In retrospect it appears they
weren’t too happy with it themselves either. They had left something of
themselves in the dark, feverish beast called “Exile On Main St.” That album
drained them, they would never reach similar peaks again.
Compared to most of what came after, “Goat’s Head Soup” isn’t that bad
actually. Their fangs are still showing, and on occasions, though not very
often unfortunately, they do ignite.
The album was recorded in Jamaica. They wanted a change of scenery, and
Jamaica was one of the few places on Earth where immigration would not block
Keith Richards’ entry. In other words, they picked Jamaica not because of
its music and culture, but because of its liberal passport control.
Of course you can’t record in Jamaica without being influenced by its lively
music scene, and in 1972/73 Kingston sure was cooking. In that respect
“Goat’s Head Soup” is a missed opportunity as the few “Jamaican” ingredients
they sprinkle over their stew is as close to the real thing as the
contemporary James Bond-movie “Live And Let Die” was. The picture of the
goat’s head soup found inside the sleeve and the sticky flirt with the
devil, “Dancing With Mr. D”, is Samedi and Kananga for rock’n’roll heads.
“Goat’s Head Soup” is a slow moving and strangely uninspired album. Keith
Richards later claimed that they hired session musicians that were so good
that the Stones willingly let themselves be relegated to the back seat. He
also thought that Mick Taylor was completely wrong for the group, they did
not need a solo guitarist, they needed a guitar player. Full stop.
Maybe he had a point. If you put on a Stones-album you’d much rather hear
Keith’s trademark rhythm rattle, both biting and loose, than being invited
to sit down and marvel at exquisite saxophone playing and Billy Preston’s
fusion dance on the keyboards.
Regarding Keith’s opinions on Taylor I am more uncertain, for it is the very
same Taylor who owns the incredibly beautifully arranged “Winter”, the best
track on the album by far, and Keith isn’t even on it.
Mentioning strong tracks we should of course include “Angie”, a stunning
ballad that is so familiar by now that half the world can sing it.
Unfortunately Jagger’s original guide vocal was not removed, it is left in
there as a disturbing ghost-like holler behind the main vocal. The moment
you become aware of this the listening experience can be quite unnerving,
particularly in headphones.
The third winner on the album is the evocative and quiet “Coming Down
Again”, sung by Keith (sometimes duetting with Mick ) with burning fervor,
it is right up there among his best vocal performances ever.
Apart from these I see no real winners. The closest thing is “Hide Your Love
“, a piano blues from the basement with a crackling guitar-run and a tight,
buttoned up Charlie. It sounds like an outtake from “Exile On Main St.”, but
doesn’t sit well with the other tracks on “Goat ‘s Head Soup”.
“Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)” is a punchy groover, dressed up in
sweeping horn blasts, but it loses steam fast and reveals itself to be a
fairly average song, and Jagger’s verbal posing doesn’t exactly help.
“100 Years Ago” never quite knows what it wants, landing flat-footed on some
sort of funky solution that fortunately is rescued by a savage guitar solo.
“Dancing With Mr. D” is all posturing and no tune, so sticky it hardly moves
at all, rotating around its own axis on a Keith-riff that could have gone
places, but doesn’t.
“Star Star” sounds like the archetypal Stones rocker, Chuck Berry-riffs
galore, but is dragged down by a “see how naughty we are”-lyric that is no
more than hollow satire. Stones rock’n’roll by the numbers.
“Silver Train” tries too hard, is sadly unrealized, burdened with weak riffs
and a desperate excuse for a melody. An outtake from 1970 that should have
remained in the vaults, but ended up as a double A-side with “Angie”. Now
what was that all about?
Remaining is the dreadful funk jam “Can You Hear The Music”, a pale relative
of the spirited and highly successful “Can’t You Hear Me Knocking” on
“Sticky Fingers”. Awful.
“Winter” is the one that almost justifies the album’s existence alone. The
Rolling Stones did not record many classics after “Exile”, but this is one
of them. The mantra-like coda with the “Moonlight Mile” string arrangement
and the phenomenal Mick Taylor solo is not of this world. “Winter” deserves
its place on any “Best Of” by The Rolling Stones.
The lack of strong up-tempo tracks on the album is a mystery. The majority
of the quality cuts they recorded were all quiet and melodic. In fact they
couldn’t fit them all in, so some had to go. Two of them, “Through The
Lonely Nights” and “Waiting On A Friend”, both better than anything that
rocks on the album, re-appeared as a B-side (in 1974) and a key track on
“Tattoo You” (in 1981).
Released: August 31, 1973
Produced By: Jimmy Miller
(All songs by Mick Jagger and Keith Richards)
1. “Dancing with Mr. D” 4:53
2. “100 Years Ago” 3:59
3. “Coming Down Again” 5:54
4. “Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)” 3:26
5. “Angie” 4:33
6. “Silver Train” 4:27
7. “Hide Your Love” 4:12
8. “Winter” 5:30
9. “Can You Hear the Music” 5:31
10. “Star Star” 4:25
The Rolling Stones:
Mick Jagger – lead and backing vocals, electric guitar on “Winter”,
harmonica on “Silver Train”, piano on “Hide Your Love”
Keith Richards – electric and acoustic guitar, backing vocals, lead vocals
on “Coming Down Again”, bass guitar on “Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)”
and “Silver Train”
Mick Taylor – electric, acoustic and slide guitar, bass guitar on “Dancing
with Mr. D” and “Coming Down Again”, backing vocals
Charlie Watts – drums
Bill Wyman – bass guitar
Nicky Hopkins – piano on “Dancing with Mr. D”, “100 Years Ago”, “Coming
Down Again”, “Angie”, “Winter”, and “Can You Hear the Music”
Billy Preston – clavinet on “100 Years Ago”, piano on “Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo
Ian Stewart – piano on “Silver Train” and “Star Star”
Bobby Keys – tenor and baritone saxophone
Jim Horn – flute and alto saxophone
Chuck Findley – trumpet
Jim Price – horn arrangement on “Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)”
Nicky Harrison – string arrangement on “Angie” and “Winter”
Anthony “Rebop” Kwaku Baah – percussion on “Dancing with Mr. D” and “Can You
Hear the Music”
Pascal (Nicholas Pascal Raicevic) – percussion on “Dancing with Mr. D” and
“Can You Hear the Music”
Jimmy Miller – percussion on “Can You Hear the Music”
Chief engineer – Andy Johns (who also mixed the album)
Assistant engineers – Carlton Lee, Howard Kilgour and Doug Bennett
Photography and sleeve design by David Bailey
25 November – 21 December 1972 and 23 May – 20 June 1973, Dynamic Sound
Studio, Kingston, Jamaica, except “Hide Your Love”, recorded at De Doelen,
Rotterdam, Netherlands, Summer 1973.